Failed Polygraph Records:
How Long Agencies May Retain the Result
Retention, hiring bars and result validity are three clocks. See NSA, ATF and DEA examples and how to request your file under the Privacy Act.
Updated October 26, 2026
Security Clearance
A failed polygraph stays on file for as long as the agency’s records schedule says, and the schedules disagree. The National Security Agency’s schedule keeps polygraph files for 35 years after closing. ATF’s applicant-screening schedules have run from 3 years to 5, and both are now inactive. How long an agency counts the result against you is a different clock again.
Key takeaways
- No universal number exists. NSA keeps polygraph files 35 years after closing; DEA’s own policy sets 5 years, and one DEA records schedule says 6 years.
- Retention is not a hiring bar. DEA’s April 2021 policy, as reported by the Justice Department’s inspector general, bars an applicant for 3 years after a significant-response result.
- “Failed” is not an official result. DoD lists five technical opinions, and the result is official only after quality-control review.
- You can ask for your file. The Privacy Act gives a right of access, but an agency can exempt a system of records, and the CIA has done so for polygraph records.
How long does a failed polygraph stay on your record?
As long as the records schedule for that agency and that type of file allows. NSA’s polygraph schedule says destroy 35 years after closing. DEA’s policy of November 2023 requires 5 years of electronic storage.
Why are hiring bars, validity and record retention three separate clocks?
Each clock answers a different question, and one agency policy can set more than one of them. At DEA, the Polygraph Screening Policy sets the bar and the eligibility period (April 2021 version) and a 5-year storage rule (November 2023 version), while a separate records schedule sets a 6-year destruction date. A date on one clock does not set the others.
| Clock | Question it answers | Who sets it | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hiring bar | How long before this agency will consider me again? | The hiring agency’s policy | DEA, April 2021 policy: 3 years after a significant-response or countermeasures result, 2 years after no opinion |
| Validity | How long does a passing result count? | Agency screening policy | DEA: a no-significant-response result keeps an applicant eligible for DEA positions that require a polygraph for 3 years. Separately, DoDI 5210.91 tells DoD components to recognize each other’s screening exams, consistent with DNI guidance, and gives no duration |
| Record retention | How long does the agency keep the file? | A records schedule approved by the National Archives, or the agency’s own policy | NSA schedule: destroy 35 years after closing. DEA: a November 2023 policy says 5 years, a records schedule says 6 |
What does an agency do with a failed result?
That depends on the agency and the position. Two models appear in the documents: a fixed bar after an unfavorable result at DEA, and a process of review, a second exam and an appeal for DoD personnel in designated positions.
DoD Instruction 5210.91 (Change 2, March 30, 2020, the version posted on the DoD issuances site) lets an examiner render only five technical opinions: No Deception Indicated, Deception Indicated, No Opinion, No Significant Response and Significant Response. The examiner’s field analysis is not an official result. The result is official only after a quality-control authority examines the data and renders a final opinion. The usual causes of a failed polygraph are a separate matter from what the agency does with the result.
The DoD rule: no action solely on a refused or unresolved exam, with two exceptions
The instruction binds the military departments, the Defense Agencies and the other DoD components. It says no unfavorable administrative action, including access, employment, assignment and detail decisions, shall be taken solely because a screening exam was refused or left unresolved, except as sections 6 and 7 of Enclosure 4 provide. A refusal or an unresolved exam goes to the appropriate authority under the component’s own procedures, and the results may be used as an investigative lead.
Sections 6 and 7 reach DoD-affiliated personnel in positions designated for a screening exam as part of initial eligibility for Top Secret, special access programs or other sensitive intelligence or operational information, or for initial assignment or detail to the CIA or another intelligence community element.
Under section 6, a person in such a position who refuses to take or complete the exam may be denied access, assignment or detail. Under section 7, an unresolved exam is forwarded to the requesting agency. If the agency finds a significant question about eligibility, the person gets an opportunity for an additional exam. If that exam also leaves questions open, the component head may start a counterintelligence investigation. On a written finding that access poses an unacceptable risk to national security, the head may also temporarily suspend access and deny an assignment or detail that depends on it, but the instruction says such a suspension may not form any part of the basis for an adverse administrative or personnel action. The person is told in writing of the determination, that it can be appealed to the component head, and that the head’s final determination is conclusive. Appeals are due within 30 days of notification.
That text binds DoD components and the people in those positions, not a private employer or another agency’s applicants. A current employee facing an unresolved exam has a different question, whether failing a polygraph costs you the job.
The DEA model: a bar measured in years
The Justice Department’s inspector general audited DEA’s polygraph program in a September 2024 report. DEA defines success as No Significant Response. Under the April 2021 policy the report shows, a Significant Response or Countermeasures result disqualifies an applicant from the position and from any other DEA position that requires a polygraph for 3 years. A No Opinion result carries 2 years.
The same report notes an April 2020 retesting policy: after any unfavorable result, a decision on another exam, following a 3-year waiting period, is made by Polygraph Unit management together with Human Resources. A waiting period is therefore a minimum, not a promise of a retest. A November 2023 version of the DEA policy exists, so check the current text before you rely on these periods.
What does a federal polygraph file contain?
More than a pass or fail line: DoD’s instruction describes a Report of Examination and a Technical Report.
The Report of Examination lists the examinee, the examiner, the requester, the relevant questions and results, the quality-control reviewers, any admissions, and the date and time. The Technical Report holds recordings of physiological test data, the test questions and results, examiner notes and quality-control observations. DEA’s casefiles also hold charts, audio tapes, Statements of Consent and medical waivers. The exam you sat, counterintelligence-scope or full-scope, changes what the questions covered, and CI and full-scope polygraphs differ in what they ask.
Copies travel. The instruction lets the customer, the party the examining organization gives the Report of Examination to, keep copies of it in an investigative case file or clearance adjudication records, under those records’ own retention policies. DEA polygraph documents may also sit in several case management systems, the inspector general found, so a file destroyed in one place can still exist in another.
Why do records schedules differ between agencies?
A records schedule is the agency’s approved instruction for how long each type of record is kept. The National Archives writes General Records Schedules for common record types, and agencies write their own for the rest.
The General Records Schedule for security management records (GRS 5.6, Transmittal 35, May 2024) shows how much depends on where a record is filed. Under item 180, records of people who were not issued clearances are destroyed 1 year after consideration of the candidate ends. Under item 181, records of people who were issued clearances are destroyed 5 years after the employee or contractor relationship ends. Both items allow longer retention if the agency needs it for business use. Items 180 and 181 cover questionnaires, summaries of investigative reports and adjudication documents. They exclude copies of the investigative reports covered in items 170 and 171, which follow the investigating agency’s instruction, and they do not name polygraph reports. Item 230, insider threat information, does list polygraph examination reports, with destruction when the data is 25 years old.
The schedule also says it does not apply to records of federal law enforcement activities, which agencies must schedule separately.
What do the NSA, ATF and DEA examples show?
They show a spread from a few years to several decades, and a schedule that changed. The rows cover different record series, so the figures are not comparable.
| Agency or schedule | Records covered | Disposition | Status or date |
|---|---|---|---|
| NSA/CSS, DAA-0457-2015-0002 | Polygraph files of every exam: examiner data, question sheets, notes, charts, technical reports, admissions | Close inactive files annually, destroy 35 years after closing | Approved November 2015 |
| ATF, N1-436-02-001, item b | Pre-employment and applicant-screening polygraph records | Cut off at the end of the calendar year, destroy 3 years after cutoff | Marked inactive, all items superseded or obsolete (reported 2/10/2022) |
| ATF, N1-436-05-002, item 2b | Pre-employment and applicant-screening polygraph records (successor to item b above) | Cut off at the end of the calendar year, destroy 5 years after cutoff | Marked inactive, all items superseded or obsolete (reported 2/10/2022) |
| DEA Polygraph Unit system, per DOJ inspector general report 24-114 | Pre-employment polygraph casefiles | Records schedule: destroy after 6 years. November 2023 policy: store 5 years | Conflict noted September 2024; DEA reviewing its schedules |
The NSA line matches DoD’s instruction to keep the Technical Report for a minimum of 35 years. It covers every polygraph file, not only unfavorable ones.
The ATF lines are a snapshot with an expiry. The earlier schedule set 3 years after cutoff, and its successor, N1-436-05-002 (item 2b), set 5. The National Archives now lists both as inactive. Its notice on the successor records ATF’s position, relayed in a December 2020 email, that its applicant-screening polygraph records are feeder information summarized in final reports, scheduled under GRS 5.2, item 020, intermediary records, destroyed upon creation or update of the final record or when no longer needed for business use, whichever is later. Confirm ATF’s current period with ATF.
The inspector general warned that a short DEA retention period could hide an earlier failure when the agency grants SCI access.
How do you request your own polygraph record?
Through the agency’s Privacy Act process, if the file sits in a system of records. The statute lets you ask to see, copy and correct it, but agencies can exempt systems by rule, so the answer can be a partial or a flat refusal.
Under 5 U.S.C. 552a, an agency that maintains a system of records must, when a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident asks, let that person review the record and have a copy made. It must also let that person ask for an amendment of anything they believe is not accurate, relevant, timely or complete, and it must acknowledge that request within 10 days, not counting weekends and legal holidays.
Subsection (k) lets an agency head exempt a system of records from the access provision by rule. Category (k)(5), investigatory material for eligibility or access to classified information, reaches only what would reveal a confidential source; other categories reach more. Subsection (j) goes further for the CIA. The CIA’s rule at 32 CFR 1901.62 exempts polygraph records from every section of the Act except a short list, and the access section is not on that list.
How should you work out a future application date?
Use the agency’s current written policy for your position, not a number from a forum or a different agency. Ask three things in order: when the bar starts, how long it runs, and whether a retest needs a manager’s approval.
Confirm which date your agency counts from. A 2019 DEA Special Agent job announcement, quoted in an August 2023 inspector general memorandum, counted 3 years from the date of the polygraph examination. DoD’s instruction treats a result as official only after quality control, so an exam date and an official result date can differ. Then check whether the waiting period guarantees a retest. Under DEA’s April 2020 policy it does not.
Do not read a retention date as permission. The 2019 DEA announcement counted its 3 years from the exam, not from the day a file is destroyed, and the April 2021 policy as the inspector general reproduces it does not say where the count starts, so ask DEA. None of this is legal advice: the hiring office, the facility security officer or an attorney decides your case.
Before you plan around any date, write to the hiring office or, for a contractor role, the facility security officer, and ask for the written polygraph policy that covers your position and the date from which each period runs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a failed polygraph stay on my record forever?
No agency named here sets a period of forever, but a period is not a promise of deletion. NSA’s polygraph schedule says destroy 35 years after closing, and GRS 5.6 item 230 says 25 years. GRS 5.6 allows longer retention for business use, and a DEA official told the inspector general that polygraph records in other systems are kept longer than 5 years. Ask the agency which schedule covers your file.
If the agency destroys the file, can I reapply?
Destruction and reapplication are separate questions. The bar is set by hiring policy, such as DEA’s 3 years, and copies of the report may survive in other case files.
Can I appeal a failed polygraph?
For DoD-affiliated personnel in designated positions, DoD Instruction 5210.91 provides a written determination and an appeal to the component head within 30 days of notification, and that head’s final determination is conclusive. DEA decides retests case by case after a waiting period. Other agencies set their own procedures.
Is “failed” the same as “unresolved”?
No. No official list uses “failed.” DoD’s technical opinions are No Deception Indicated, Deception Indicated, No Opinion, No Significant Response and Significant Response. The instruction calls an exam unresolved when the examinee is unable to resolve all relevant questions (Enclosure 4, section 7). An examiner’s field call does not count until quality control renders the final opinion, so ask which result was recorded.
Can I get a copy of my polygraph file?
You can ask under the Privacy Act. The agency may provide the record, provide part of it, or refuse because the system is exempt. The CIA has exempted its polygraph records from the access provision (32 CFR 1901.62(a)(1)), and in some cases its rule lets the Agency neither confirm nor deny that a record exists (1901.62(c)). Start with the agency’s privacy office.