Guideline J Criminal Conduct:
Charges, Convictions, and Patterns
What SEAD 4 Guideline J weighs beyond a conviction: charges, dismissals, patterns, probation, recency, rehabilitation, and what the SF-86 asks.
Updated October 26, 2026
Security Clearance
Guideline J, Criminal Conduct, is paragraphs 30 through 32 of SEAD 4, the national security adjudicative guidelines in effect since June 8, 2017. It asks whether a person’s conduct raises doubt about judgment, reliability, and trustworthiness. A conviction is one way to show that. The text names others, and it also lists what can reduce the concern.
Key takeaways
1. Paragraph 31(b) reaches evidence of criminal conduct “regardless of whether the individual was formally charged, prosecuted, or convicted.”
2. Guideline J lists 5 conditions that may be disqualifying and 4 that may mitigate. Each one is a factor to weigh, not an automatic result.
3. SF-86 Section 22 tells you to report within its scope even if the record was sealed, expunged, or the charge dismissed, with one narrow federal exception, plus a separate traffic-citation carve-out explained below.
4. Current probation or parole, a violation or revocation, and failure to finish a court-mandated rehabilitation program each have their own line in paragraph 31.
5. Compliance with probation or parole terms appears in paragraph 32(d) as rehabilitation evidence, next to restitution, education, and employment record.
How does Guideline J treat criminal conduct beyond a conviction?
Paragraph 31(b) lists evidence of criminal conduct as a possible disqualifying condition even when the person was never charged, prosecuted, or convicted. Evidence can include a credible allegation, an admission, and matters of official record. Paragraph 32(c) runs the other way: no reliable evidence that the person committed the offense is a mitigating condition.
The SEAD 4 text is built around conduct and the evidence for it. The conviction is one kind of evidence, and the guideline never makes it the only kind.
Paragraph 31 introduces its list as “conditions that could raise a security concern and may be disqualifying,” and neither list produces a result by itself. SEAD 4 calls the method the whole-person concept: all available, reliable information about the person, past and present, favorable and unfavorable, is considered. The site’s post on how adjudicators weigh mitigation against a disqualifying fact covers that weighing in more detail.
Each stage of a criminal matter touches a different Guideline J condition and a different SF-86 Section 22 question. The SF-86 posted by the Office of Personnel Management is the November 2016 revision, so check your edition.
| Stage of the record | What SEAD 4 Guideline J says | What SF-86 Section 22 asks |
|---|---|---|
| Conduct with no police contact | 31(b): evidence of the conduct counts whether or not there was a formal charge, prosecution, or conviction | The questions are framed around citations, arrests, charges, convictions, sentences, probation or parole, and pending trials |
| Arrest | No condition names an arrest as such; the underlying conduct is what 31(b) tests | Asks whether you were arrested in the last seven years |
| Charge, then dismissal or a not-guilty finding | 32(c) lists “no reliable evidence to support that the individual committed the offense” as mitigation | Asks about charges in the last seven years, and for each listed offense every charge and its outcome, with found not-guilty, charge dropped, and nolle pros as examples; within that scope a dismissal does not remove the duty to report |
| Conviction | 31(b) names being convicted as one route, not the only one | Asks about charges, convictions, and sentences in the last seven years, plus separate EVER questions for listed categories |
| Probation or parole | 31(c) current status; 31(d) violation, revocation, or failure to finish a court-mandated rehabilitation program; 32(d) compliance as rehabilitation evidence | Asks whether you were or are on probation or parole in the last seven years, and for the dates |
Compare the arrest and dismissal rows. A dismissal tells you how a court case ended. Paragraph 32(c) asks a different question, which is whether reliable evidence shows the person did it. The guideline does not say a dismissal closes the matter, and it does not say a dismissal proves guilt. It points the adjudicator at the evidence.
How do an arrest, a charge, and a disposition differ on the record?
They are separate events, and the SF-86 asks for them separately. For each offense it lists, Section 22 requests every charge and the outcome of each charged offense. If you were found guilty of or pleaded guilty to a lesser offense, it tells you to list both the original charge and the lesser offense.
A story like “I was arrested once and it went away” can hide a citation, two charges, a reduced plea, and a sentence.
The instruction paragraph in Section 22 is broad. It says to report information within the section “regardless of whether the record in your case has been sealed, expunged, or otherwise stricken from the court record, or the charge was dismissed,” and to include incidents abroad. One exception follows immediately: convictions under the Federal Controlled Substances Act for which a court issued an expungement order under 21 U.S.C. 844 or 18 U.S.C. 3607 need not be reported.
A second narrow carve-out sits on the citation question only. The parenthetical there says not to check the box if all the citations involved traffic infractions where the fine was less than $300 and did not include alcohol or drugs. It is not attached to the arrest question or the charge question.
One conviction category also has its own statute. Appendix B of SEAD 4 summarizes the Bond Amendment, under which agency heads may not grant or renew access to SCI, SAP, or Restricted Data for someone convicted in a U.S. court of a crime, sentenced to imprisonment for a term exceeding one year, and incarcerated as a result for not less than one year. The same appendix says a meritorious waiver may be appropriate if the adjudicator would otherwise have reached a favorable decision. It is a statutory limit that applies alongside the weighing in Guideline J, which footnote 3 of the guideline points to.
What counts as a pattern across different kinds of offenses?
Paragraph 31(a) describes a pattern of minor offenses, any one of which on its own would be unlikely to affect an eligibility decision, but which in combination cast doubt on judgment, reliability, or trustworthiness. The text does not limit the pattern to one kind of offense.
The paragraph describes a combination of offenses, not a single event, so the question becomes what the events show together.
Guideline E, Personal Conduct, adds a related route. Its paragraph 16(d) covers credible adverse information not explicitly covered under any other guideline, and it lists “a pattern of dishonesty or rule violations.” Rule violations that are not criminal offenses can therefore be weighed as a pattern too.
The nine factors in SEAD 4 paragraph 2(d) include “the frequency and recency of the conduct” and “the likelihood of continuation or recurrence.” Those are the questions a pattern raises. With more than one entry on your record, a timeline helps: date, what happened, how each matter ended, and what changed between entries.
What do probation, parole, and court orders change?
Being on parole or probation now is itself a listed condition in paragraph 31(c). Paragraph 31(d) adds violation or revocation of parole or probation, and failure to complete a court-mandated rehabilitation program. Paragraph 32(d) treats compliance with parole or probation terms as rehabilitation evidence.
The same fact therefore appears on both sides of the guideline. Current supervision is something the adjudicator weighs, and a record of compliance is something you can point to.
The SF-86 asks whether you have been or are on probation or parole in the last seven years. It also asks whether you are currently on trial or awaiting a trial, and for conviction-related entries it asks for the dates of probation or parole, including whether it is still ongoing. Section 22.3 asks separately whether a domestic violence protective order or restraining order is currently issued against you, and requests the date, the issuing court or agency, and an explanation.
Anything a court ordered, such as classes, treatment, community service, or restitution, belongs in your records with a date of completion. The guideline names failure to complete a court-mandated rehabilitation program as its own condition, so proof that you finished one answers a specific question.
How do recency and circumstances change the weight of an offense?
SEAD 4 paragraph 2(d) lists nine factors, including seriousness, circumstances, frequency and recency, age and maturity at the time, and the likelihood of recurrence. Paragraph 32(a) credits time elapsed or unusual circumstances when recurrence is unlikely and reliability is not in doubt.
Recency works in two directions. Paragraph 32(a) turns on time elapsed with no recurrence. A recent event, or an old one followed by new ones, is harder to fit within it.
Paragraph 32(b) lists pressure or coercion that was present at the time and is no longer part of the person’s life. Paragraph 2(d)(2) asks about the circumstances surrounding the conduct, including knowledgeable participation.
Two sentences from the same section frame all of this. Each case “must be judged on its own merits,” and “any doubt concerning personnel being considered for national security eligibility will be resolved in favor of the national security.” The first means no checklist decides a case. The second is a reason to close gaps in your record before an adjudicator finds them.
What rehabilitation evidence reduces the likelihood of recurrence?
Paragraph 32(d) asks for evidence of successful rehabilitation and gives examples: the passage of time without recurrence, restitution, compliance with parole or probation terms, job training or higher education, a good employment record, or constructive community involvement. The list says “including, but not limited to,” so it is not a checklist.
Each example can be backed by a record someone else can verify: the absence of new entries, payment records for restitution, completion paperwork, transcripts and certificates, performance reviews, and dated, named community activity.
Factor (6) in paragraph 2(d) asks about “the presence or absence of rehabilitation and other permanent behavioral changes.” Evidence that has held over time speaks to the word permanent more directly than a plan does.
Neither list promises an outcome. The authorized adjudicative agency makes the determination, and the weight each item carries depends on the facts of the case. For questions about your own record, the right people are a facility security officer at the sponsoring employer and, for legal questions, an attorney.
How do criminal and personal-conduct disclosures check each other?
Guideline E treats deliberate omission, concealment, or falsification of relevant facts on a security questionnaire as a possible disqualifying condition (paragraph 16(a)). An incomplete criminal-history answer can therefore raise a concern separate from the offense itself.
The two guidelines can apply to the same facts. An old misdemeanor that fits paragraph 32(a) can be mitigated. A deliberate omission about that misdemeanor is its own question, under a different guideline, about candor. The mitigating conditions differ too. Paragraph 17(a) lists “prompt, good-faith efforts to correct the omission, concealment, or falsification before being confronted with the facts.” The site’s post on how missing SF-86 information affects eligibility goes into that problem.
Disclosure continues after a clearance is granted, but the duty binds particular people. SEAD 3 lists arrests as reportable for individuals with access to Secret and Confidential information, L access, or a non-critical sensitive position (Section G.2.c), and for those with Top Secret access, Q access, or a critical or special sensitive position (Section H.2.c). For contractors, DCSA says the tier follows eligibility for access, not the level currently accessed. Under 32 CFR 117.8, contractors and their cleared employees must report certain events, and contractors must report adverse information about employees determined eligible for access, without relying on rumor or innuendo.
DCSA’s FAQ on the NISPOM rule adds a practical point for contractors: report criminal conduct such as arrests in DISS, then update the system with the disposition as it occurs. For contractors in the National Industrial Security Program, the same FAQ says the SEAD 3 requirements apply only to cleared contractor personnel with eligibility for access, while SF-86 duties apply regardless of SEAD 3. A contractor candidate without eligibility yet answers to the SF-86 and the application process, not to that reporting duty.
The site’s post on keeping a clearance after an arrest covers the reporting side. DCSA’s security awareness site also carries a short training module titled Adjudicative Guideline J: Criminal Conduct, and the site’s earlier post on criminal conduct and your security clearance gives the basic overview.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Guideline J apply if I was never convicted?
It can. Paragraph 31(b) reaches evidence of criminal conduct regardless of whether the person was formally charged, prosecuted, or convicted, and it names a credible allegation, an admission, and matters of official record as kinds of evidence. Paragraph 32(c) lists no reliable evidence that the person committed the offense as mitigation, so the question is what the evidence shows.
Do I list a dismissed or sealed charge on the SF-86?
Section 22 says to report within its scope regardless of whether the record was sealed, expunged, or stricken, or the charge was dismissed. The exception is a conviction under the Federal Controlled Substances Act for which a court issued an expungement order under 21 U.S.C. 844 or 18 U.S.C. 3607. Read the instructions on the form you are given, and ask a facility security officer or an attorney about your own entries.
Is one minor offense enough to cost a clearance?
Paragraph 31(a) describes a pattern, and its own wording says any one of the offenses on its own would be unlikely to affect an eligibility decision. The concern is the combination. Paragraph 31(b) and the nine factors in 2(d) still apply to a single event, so the outcome depends on the facts of the case.
Does probation mean I cannot be cleared?
Being on parole or probation is a condition that could raise a concern and may be disqualifying under paragraph 31(c). It is not described as an automatic bar, and paragraph 32 lists conditions that could mitigate. The authorized adjudicative agency makes the call on the whole record.
What should I do first if I have a record?
Request the court record for each entry, then write one line per entry with the date, the charge, the outcome, any sentence, and the date each court-ordered condition was completed. Check each line against the SF-86 Section 22 fields before you submit or update the form.