Revocation vs. Suspension vs. Denial: Three Different Clearance Events

Posted by Ashley Jones

To revoke a security clearance is to withdraw national security eligibility that an adjudicator had already granted, for cause. A denial is an unfavorable result when eligibility was requested. A suspension is a temporary removal while a case is still open. A denial and a revocation both end in an unfavorable determination with the same reply and appeal steps, while a suspension is a holding action that ends in a new determination. Each word starts a different notice and a different next question, so a headline that treats them as synonyms leaves out the part you need.

The labels. A 2006 OPM notice told federal agencies how to report clearance actions to OPM’s own database. It defined denied as “clearance denied following adjudication,” revoked as “clearance withdrawn for cause,” and suspended as “clearance temporarily withdrawn for cause.” DoD kept its clearances in its own system.

Reconsideration. After a final denial or revocation, the earliest a security office can ask DCSA for reconsideration is one year later. The clearance stays denied or revoked in the meantime.

Suspensions. DoD tells adjudication offices to monitor any suspension past 180 days closely.

Look-alikes. An administrative withdrawal, a loss of jurisdiction, a debriefing, and a withdrawn temporary clearance each follow their own rules.

For employers
Hiring cleared professionals?
Post your cleared req where security-cleared candidates already search.

Post a Cleared Job

For job seekers
Holding a clearance?
Browse cleared roles from employers hiring right now.

Browse Cleared Jobs

How do eligibility, access, and employment differ?

Eligibility is the government’s finding that you meet the standards for classified information. Access is permission to see particular information and also needs a need-to-know and a signed nondisclosure agreement. Employment is your employer’s decision. Executive Order 12968 keeps eligibility decisions separate from hiring and retention.

Executive Order 12968, as published in the Federal Register in 1995, says employees are not to be granted access unless they have a favorable eligibility determination, a demonstrated need-to-know, and a signed nondisclosure agreement (section 1.2(c)). Orders in 2008 and 2017 amended other parts of it, such as adding continuous evaluation, and left the sections cited here as written.

Section 2.1(a) adds that eligibility determinations “are separate from suitability determinations with respect to the hiring or retention of persons for employment by the government or any other personnel actions.” For a cleared contractor, 32 CFR 117.10(a)(2)(ii) says the company “will immediately deny access to classified information to any employee when notified of a denial, revocation, or suspension of eligibility.” That sentence is about access. What happens to the position depends on the employer and the contract. The post on what happens if your clearance is suspended or revoked follows the employment side.

What is a security clearance denial?

A denial is an unfavorable eligibility decision reached after adjudication. OPM’s 2006 reporting code reads “clearance denied following adjudication.” The word fits a request that ended unfavorably, since a person who held no eligibility has nothing to revoke. For DoD civilians and Service members, the manual allows one only after the person has been offered the chance to reply, and the letter carries instructions for appeal.

Executive Order 12968’s review protections reach “applicants and employees who are determined to not meet the standards,” so the same steps cover someone being considered for a job and someone already working. Section 5.2(a) promises a written explanation as detailed as national security and other law permit, a reasonable opportunity to reply in writing, written notice of the result and of the right to appeal, an appeal to a panel of at least three members, and an opportunity to appear personally at some point in the process, as the agency head decides.

Several limits come with those promises. Section 5.2(c) says the section “creates no procedural or substantive rights.” Section 5.2(d) lets an agency head certify that a procedure cannot be offered in a particular case without revealing classified information, and section 5.2(e) preserves an agency head’s power to deny or terminate access to classified information where the section 5.2(a) procedures cannot be invoked consistently with national security. DoD’s manual repeats both in paragraph 10.2.h. Agency heads write their own implementing regulations, so the procedures for your category control.

What does it mean to revoke a security clearance?

Revocation takes away eligibility a person already held. The 2006 OPM reporting code reads “clearance withdrawn for cause.” It follows an unfavorable adjudication and, ordinarily, a written explanation and a chance to reply. Until you receive the letter of revocation, the paper in your hand may be only a proposal, such as a letter of intent with a statement of reasons. The letter of revocation itself states the final determination and carries instructions for appeal.

OPM’s Federal Investigations Notice 06-03, dated April 13, 2006, told federal agencies how to report clearance actions to OPM’s central database. It says clearances granted by the Department of Defense “are not maintained in CVS,” OPM’s system, and are checked in DoD’s own system. It is a data notice, so it supplies vocabulary only, and DoD’s manual and the DCSA FAQ use the same three terms for DoD and industry cases. For a contractor employee, 32 CFR 117.10(a)(1) says the CSA is responsible for determining eligibility, and (a)(2)(i) says the CSA “will notify the contractor when an employee’s eligibility has been denied, suspended, or revoked.” That covers the notice to the company. The notice to you follows the procedure for your category.

For DoD civilians and Service members, DoD Manual 5200.02 (April 3, 2017, Change 1 effective October 29, 2020) says the letter of intent to deny or revoke “must accompany or include” a written statement of reasons. You tell the adjudication facility within 10 calendar days whether you will reply, and the reply is due within 30 calendar days of receipt, with extensions possible. The facility then issues a letter of denial or revocation with “clear instructions on how to appeal.”

Contractor employees follow DoD Directive 5220.6, a 1992 directive reissued through Change 4 on April 20, 1999. An unfavorable decision “shall not be made” without a written statement of reasons, and the answer must reach DOHA within 20 days of receipt. If no timely, responsive answer arrives, DOHA “may discontinue processing the case, deny issuance of the requested security clearance, and direct” revocation of any clearance held. The deadline in your own letter is the one that counts.

What is a security clearance suspension?

A suspension temporarily removes eligibility or access while a case is open. OPM’s 2006 code reads “clearance temporarily withdrawn for cause.” In DoD’s manual it happens at two levels: a commander can suspend local access, and an adjudication facility can suspend eligibility.

The manual (paragraph 9.4) says commanders and Component heads “may suspend access for cause” when information under any adjudicative guideline “raises a serious question” about the person’s ability or intent to protect national security information. The adjudication facility evaluates credible derogatory information within 15 calendar days and makes an initial determination on continued eligibility. Contractor cases are the exception: paragraph 9.4.a sends them to the suspension standards in DoDD 5220.6 and Volume 2 of DoDM 5220.22.

You are told in writing, with “a brief statement of the reason(s).” Once the incident report is finalized, the facility “will render a new national security eligibility determination.”

The manual states no end date. Suspension cases “must be resolved as quickly as circumstances permit,” and suspensions past 180 days must be “closely monitored and managed.” If the suspension began with a continuous vetting alert, the separate post on a clearance suspended under continuous vetting covers that starting point.

How do denial, revocation, and suspension compare side by side?

Sort them by whether eligibility was held before, whether the action is temporary or final, and which notice starts review. Denial and revocation carry appeal rights; a suspension is a holding action that ends in a new determination.

Question Denial Revocation Suspension
Was eligibility held before? Usually no. A request ended unfavorably. Yes. It is withdrawn for cause. Yes. It is temporarily withdrawn for cause.
Temporary or final? Final once review rights run out. Final once review rights run out. Temporary. It ends in a new determination.
What happens to access? None is granted on that eligibility. A contractor must deny access on notice. Access ends. A contractor must deny access on notice. A contractor must deny access on notice. In DoD, a commander can also suspend local access.
Which notice controls review? Letter of denial (DoD civilians and Service members) or the DOHA process after a statement of reasons (contractors). Letter of revocation, or the DOHA process after a statement of reasons. The written suspension notice, then the new determination. An unfavorable result goes through the notice-and-appeal steps.

Which events sound like a revocation but are not?

An administrative withdrawal, access that ended because the work ended, a loss of jurisdiction, a no-determination-made entry, and a debriefing can all look like revocations without being one. Each has its own rule. A debriefing can follow a revocation but is given for other reasons too, so it cannot tell you which one applies.

Entry or event What the sources say
Administrative withdrawal OPM’s 2006 code calls it “administratively withdrawn, non-derogatory.” DoD’s manual excludes from unfavorable determinations withdrawals “based on changed duties or similar circumstances unrelated to a national security eligibility adjudication.” DCSA says data-quality checks that find breaks in service or no U.S. citizenship listed in DISS can cause one, and eligibility can be recertified if the component asks.
Access ended because the work ended A contractor may administratively terminate access “solely because of no current requirement for such access” (32 CFR 117.10(i)). If the person has stayed employed, remains eligible, has a current investigation of sufficient scope, and no new derogatory information is known, the contractor may restore access based on CSA guidance. Adverse information must still be reported while the person remains eligible.
Loss of jurisdiction The person ended DoD affiliation before an eligibility determination could be made. The facility records eligibility of “none,” and the security manager or FSO must submit a new request to restart adjudication.
No determination made DCSA says it means there is “inadequate information” to make a favorable or an unfavorable determination.
Debriefing The manual calls for a termination briefing when employment ends, when national security eligibility is withdrawn, and in certain other absences, so one can accompany a revocation but does not show that one happened.

Does a withdrawn temporary clearance predict the final decision?

The rules do not say it does. For contractor employees, 32 CFR 117.10(l)(4) lets the CSA withdraw temporary eligibility when derogatory information develops, “pending completion of the processing” that leads to the final decision. Paragraph (l)(6) says that withdrawal “is not a denial, termination, or revocation” and “may not be appealed.”

The final decision is a separate act, and an unfavorable one goes through the notice and appeal steps. In the contractor rule, temporary eligibility was previously called interim, and it “shall not exceed one year” unless the CSA approves more. For DoD civilians and Service members, the manual likewise leaves “withdrawals of interim eligibility based on derogatory information” out of unfavorable determinations (paragraph 9.1.a). Once a denial or revocation is final, DCSA says the person “cannot be granted interim eligibility or access” while the clearance remains denied or revoked.

What can you do after a denial or revocation letter?

Use the appeal route in your notice, then, if the appeal fails, wait for an employer-supported request. DCSA’s adjudications FAQ says civilian and military personnel can appeal in writing to their Component’s Personnel Security Appeals Board or through a personal appearance at DOHA, while industry personnel must appeal to DOHA.

For DoD civilians and Service members, the manual has you return a notice of intent to appeal within 10 calendar days of receiving the letter of denial or revocation, and a written appeal goes to the board within 30 calendar days of receipt. The guide to the appeal process after a clearance is taken away walks through that stage.

The appeal authority’s decision, DCSA says, “is final.” Afterward the person’s security office may submit a reconsideration request no earlier than one year after the final denial or revocation. “Reconsideration is not an action that is available to individuals; only an employing organization may ask for reconsideration,” and the FAQ adds that “No Due Process or appeal rights are afforded to the individual.” The organization may instead request a new background investigation after the same year. Under the DoD manual, “passage of time alone is not a sufficient criterion,” and reconsideration “is not a personal right or entitlement.” For DoD civilians and Service members the manual also requires an operational need and a person “selected or tentatively selected for a national security position.” For contractor employees, DoD Directive 5220.6 bars reapplication “for 1 year from the date of the initial unfavorable clearance decision,” while DCSA counts from the final denial or revocation, so ask your FSO which applies. The post on reapplying for a security clearance after a denial or revocation covers the application side.

None of this is legal advice. Your security manager or facility security officer can tell you which procedure applies, and a qualified attorney can advise on your case.

What should you ask the security office when the label is unclear?

Ask the security office that owns your record, not DCSA directly. The FAQ says individuals are prohibited from contacting its adjudications unit about their own clearance and must go through their Security Management Office or, in industry, their Facility Security Officer. Ask these:

  • What status does the system of record show today: denied, revoked, suspended, administratively withdrawn, loss of jurisdiction, or no determination made?
  • Is the paper I received a proposal, such as a statement of reasons, or the final letter?
  • Who issued it, and what is its date?
  • Does it affect my eligibility, my local access, or both?
  • What reply or appeal route does the notice give, and by what date?
  • If the time comes, who at my employer can ask for reconsideration or a new investigation?
ClearedJobs.NET connects cleared talent with the employers who need it.
Whether you are hiring for a cleared req or holding a clearance and looking, start here.

Post a Cleared JobBrowse Cleared Jobs

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a suspended clearance the same as a revoked one?

No. OPM’s 2006 reporting codes, written for federal agencies, define a suspension as a clearance “temporarily withdrawn for cause” and a revocation as one “withdrawn for cause.” In DoD’s manual, a suspension ends with a new eligibility determination once the incident report is finalized.

Can a revoked clearance be reinstated?

Not automatically. DCSA says the security office may request reconsideration no earlier than one year after the final denial or revocation, or the organization may request a new background investigation after the same year. The individual cannot make either request, and the clearance stays revoked in the meantime.

Does a debriefing mean my clearance was revoked?

Not by itself. DoD’s manual calls for a termination briefing when employment ends, when national security eligibility is withdrawn, and in certain other absences, so a debriefing can follow a revocation but can also follow a job change. It does not tell you which happened.

What should I do with a statement of reasons?

Read the reply instructions and dates in it and treat them as the deadline. For DoD civilians and Service members the manual sets 30 calendar days to reply. For contractor employees, DoDD 5220.6 sets 20 days from receipt for the answer to reach DOHA. A missed or unresponsive answer can end in denial or revocation, so bring the letter to your FSO or an attorney quickly.

Does a loss of jurisdiction mean I lost my clearance?

Not by that entry alone. It means your affiliation ended before an eligibility determination could be made. A new security manager or FSO can ask DCSA to restart adjudication once you are affiliated again.

Author

  • Ashley Jones is ClearedJobs.Net's blog Editor and a cleared job search expert, dedicated to helping security-cleared job seekers and employers navigate job search and recruitment challenges. With in-depth experience assisting cleared job seekers and transitioning military personnel at in-person and virtual Cleared Job Fairs and military base hiring events, Ashley has a deep understanding of the unique needs of the cleared community. She is also the Editor of ClearedJobs.Net's job search podcast, Security Cleared Jobs: Who's Hiring & How.

    View all posts

Comment

Notify me of updates to this conversation

Author

  • Ashley Jones is ClearedJobs.Net's blog Editor and a cleared job search expert, dedicated to helping security-cleared job seekers and employers navigate job search and recruitment challenges. With in-depth experience assisting cleared job seekers and transitioning military personnel at in-person and virtual Cleared Job Fairs and military base hiring events, Ashley has a deep understanding of the unique needs of the cleared community. She is also the Editor of ClearedJobs.Net's job search podcast, Security Cleared Jobs: Who's Hiring & How.

    View all posts
This entry was posted on Sunday, November 15, 2026 8:24 am